Sutherland Press building demolition decision deferred


If the elements don’t hasten the demise of the Sutherland Press building, time spent in protracted court battles may ultimately prove the enemy of the derelict structure.

As the result of a technicality presented May 27 of this year to Justice Gorman by building owner David McGee, no decision has been reached as to whether the city can proceed with demolition of the Talbot Street building dating back to 1913.

In a decision delivered Tuesday, Justice Gorman declined to rule on McGee’s request for an injunction to halt demolition of the four-storey structure deemed unsafe by city engineers.

Instead, Justice Gorman did accept McGee’s submission at the May hearing in the Elgin County Courthouse that Sutherland Loft Inc. did not receive notice of a building order and its president was unaware, specifically, the building might be demolished if not remediated by the owner.

In March, the city advised McGee via registered mail that demolition of the building would begin at the end of that month because of noncompliance with a property standards order. The order called for immediate replacement of spalling or damaged bricks and securing the roof, which had suffered a partial collapse.

McGee’s lawyer, Valerie M’Garry, argued because McGee’s signature was not on the registered letter delivery receipt then, in fact, he did not get the notice from the city.
City manager Wendell Graves indicated Justice Gorman referred to the mail snafu as improper procedure on delivery of notice.

The city will review this decision with its legal counsel to determine the next steps, added Graves.

“The safety of the building was not discussed one way or another,” in Justice Gorman’s decision, noted Graves.

“We have reviewed info from our structural engineer and the building remains unsafe,” he stressed.

Due to the ongoing safety concerns, the city will close a section of Moore Street, from Talbot Street southward to the Moore Street parking lot, effective today.

“The Moore Street parking lot will remain open,” said Graves. “While Talbot Street in front of the building will remain open, the sidewalk will be closed. Additionally, the transit building will be closed because of its proximity to the east wall of the Sutherland Press building.”

Day-to-day operations of the transit building will be temporarily moved to South Edgeware Road, where space is available at the Community Recycling Centre.

“We cannot risk the public safety,” said Graves.

Related posts:

After eight years, where might the money be?

Sutherland stalling hits ratepayers in the pocket

A little good news on the Alma College front

Round 1 in Demo Derby #2 goes to St. Thomas

Sutherland insurance policy is somewhat reassuring

Should city consider purchasing its downtown nemesis?

What’s next in the Sutherland saga?

The city is playing politics insists Sutherland Press building owner

Sutherland Press building demolition on hold again

Time for straight talk on the future of Alma property

Will council give green light to Sutherland Press building demolition?

STEGH job cuts revive that old two-step episode

Round 2 of demolition derby announced

Sutherland Press building roof collapse raises significant concerns

The Sutherland Press building is on a slow simmer

Derelict building a reminder of dirty politics

Sutherland Press building a backdrop for smear campaign

Not the end of the Sutherland Press saga


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s