Joy Dawdy’s swimming lessons earn a reprieve; however, some conditions will apply

The days of treading water for the owner of 21 Philip Street are over, at least for the time being.
At Monday’s meeting of city council (Dec. 8), members unanimously agreed to direct staff to design a temporary bylaw, allowing Dawdy to continue offering swimming lessons in her backyard pool, likely for a period of three years.
Something she has done for more than three decades.
Staff were not recommending Official Plan and zoning bylaw amendments in a report to council from Michelle Knieriem, Manager of Planning Services.
She concluded, “Staff understand and appreciate that the swimming lessons provided by the applicant are valued by many members of the community. While this value is noted, staff recommend refusal of the Official Plan and Zoning Bylaw Amendment applications due to issues of compatibility.

Knieriem added, “Staff noted the possibility of council considering a Temporary Use By-law to allow the use to operate for up to three years, subject to certain conditions.”
And that is the option that council unanimously opted for.
Although Coun. Steve Wookey’s remarks to open up discussion no doubt felt like the water had just been muddied.
He began, “I’m going to say something that everyone in this room has heard me say 20 times in the last decade, and that’s that governance by exception is poor governance.
“What I mean by that is when we do a major departure from a situation, and we make certain decisions, then we create confusion among ourselves, among staff and among the public.
“So, for instance, in this case, I’d love to see lessons continue. Having said that, we know the kind of thing that’s going to come next, and I’m going to give a few examples, and I’m sorry to take some time.”
Wookey then listed several scenarios based on home-based businesses and how their initial scope could potentially far exceed the initial intention.
Wookey continued, “So my argument is that once we open the door, we really are saying we don’t know what a residential zone is anymore, and that’s a challenge for us.
“Having said that, I would like to see a temporary zone set up for this so that this business has a landing strip.
“And how that looks with the temporary zone, if we do it, as I understand it, we can create the goalposts as we need to, so that there is some cushion here.
“I would like to see this business continue, but I cannot support a change in zoning that opens the door to many, many other things. And it creates a challenge that I don’t think we’re prepared to go down.
“Now, having said that, if my colleagues want to talk about this bylaw, I would love to talk about this bylaw to say, are we permitting the right things in residential backyards? But I would strongly encourage us to do that first, to talk about the policy first before we do exceptions to it.”

“I find it hard to believe that five kids can make so much noise in an afternoon learning swimming lessons.”

Coun. Jeff Kohler followed with these observations.
“I, too, have concerns . . . but I’d like to see the lessons continue with some guidelines in there. I know during the public meeting, I listened to both sides. I did hear that both sides were willing to have some sort of compromise.
“And when I talked to Joy, she said that she would have appreciated having that conversation before because she’s more than willing to compromise.”
Coun. Jim Herbert was in agreement with the previous two speakers.
“We’re agreeing that we want to see the swimming lessons continue, and when I was reading the report, it says that the weekend lessons had stopped. So, there’s some movement there.
“And I had a little concern that they said the opinion from the noise from backyard swimming lessons exceeds the noise expected in a residential area.
“I find it hard to believe that five kids can make so much noise in an afternoon learning swimming lessons. I think of all the noise we have at the park when the bands come in, and people complain about the noise. “
And so, council will await a staff report with a proposed temporary bylaw that one hopes is a valid compromise for all parties involved.
Related post:
BORING AND PREDICTABLE IS IN FOR THE COMING YEAR
Tuesday evening at the Elgin County Administration Building, Malahide Mayor Dominique Giguere was acclaimed County of Elgin Warden for 2026.
In her acceptance speech, Giguere (seen below with Deputy Warden Grant Jones) took time to thank past wardens, some of whom were in attendance.
“I’ve learned a lot from each of you, and I consider it an honour to follow in your footsteps. I do not take lightly, nor for granted, the decision that was made this evening.”
As County of Elgin Warden for the coming year, Giguere emphasized the importance of thoughtful leadership on key priorities and promised a year of stability and clarity.
“Whatever we can control, we should control. How we govern, how we make decisions, and how we work together.
“That’s all within our control. We can keep that very civil, predictable and stable. And then that will make us better positioned to actually deal with everything else that is unpredictable and uncertain right now.

“If you have 100 priorities, then you have no priorities.”

“There’s just so much uncertainty. So I think this group, we’ve got that momentum and we can provide that.”
Asked if she had priorities for the coming year, Giguere stressed, “We do have a strategic plan with a set of priorities.
“So the plan is just to stay the course, speaking of stability.
“But I will be meeting with each councillor to say, so now we’ve got one year for this term of council, what’s on everybody’s top list?
“And see if we can maybe shorten those priorities. We’re not going to be able to do everything that’s in the plan. It’s a long-term plan. But based on everything that we know now, everything that we want to accomplish, we’re going to be working with staff, with our CAO, with council to maybe sharpen that, narrow down what those goals are just for 2026.”
She added, “If you have 100 priorities, then you have no priorities.”
Giguere continued, “So we’re going to sharpen that vision a little bit for that finish line. It’s a little fuzzy right now, but through good conversations, we’re going to sharpen that image and be able to be totally focused on it.
“That’s why we don’t take it for granted. So we need to keep talking. Have the conversations, have the debates. And make those decisions. At the end of the day, we have to deliver them.
“We also have to be decisive.”
Infrastructure, she pointed out, is one area where council will have to focus its attention in the coming year, while not placing a heavy burden on ratepayers.
“It’s no breaking news to say that we have a lot of challenging years ahead. All the infrastructure that was built 20, 30, 40 years ago is all coming to the forefront.
“And we’ve got to be very strategic again on how we’re going to prioritize it. There’s a lot of work to do on the infrastructure side. And I’m looking forward to a lot of good conversations about that. Because we’ll have to prioritize it.”
Giguere noted there is no shortage of agenda items to deal with, and council is not going to waste any time getting started. In fact, her first council meeting as warden was Thursday morning.
“So we’re not wasting any time, and that’s why we’re looking at the transportation master plan already. Approving that hopefully with council.
The plan itself identifies key directions that we want to follow. Still, there are lots of decisions to be made in terms of the specific action plan and how we’re going to fund all that. But, yeah, we’re not wasting any time.”
She wears the crown, the guardian of the lanes, and manager of the hat, and that will be her focus moving forward.

“That’s right, seven years’ worth of hearing me say the same thing. But as I said, I’m all for boring and predictable when it comes to politics.”

“So if anything, that’s going to be my focus as the leader now of the county, to make sure that our decisions are while we’re wearing the right hat. That means the decisions have to be for the benefit of the county. And the decisions are also going to be within their lane.
“So if I have any pet project, it’s more of a pet approach. And my colleagues are very familiar with my broken record. Seven years’ worth.
“That’s right, seven years’ worth of hearing me say the same thing. But as I said, I’m all for boring and predictable when it comes to politics.”
As is the custom, past Warden Grant Jones will serve this coming year as Deputy Warden.
THE NEED FOR ADDITIONAL LONG-TERM CARE BEDS
In her first council meeting in three years, Coun. Joan Rymal made her presence felt.
When it came time for new business near the end of the meeting, she noted that when the city begins to realize the municipal property tax benefits from the PowerCo EV gigafactory – likely not until the mid-2030s – there would be a need to address the requirement for a second long-term care facility to augment the existing Valleyview Home.
“Currently, Valleyview has 136 beds,” noted Rymal, “but the waiting list is 423, which is huge.
“There are 225 employees there, so when you think of PowerCo and Vianode coming, having another long-term care home would certainly provide great employment.
“So having those steps in place, it might be helpful to have that as part of our strategic planning moving forward.”
“Council over the next year will be spending a great deal of time looking at the strategic plan to see where we are on each of the items.”
That drew the attention of Mayor Joe Preston, who praised, “You are hitting all the right buttons right from the first day.”
REVIVING A TRADITION
In a report to council for Monday’s (Dec. 15), Taylor Mooney, Strategic Initiatives Manager, advises, “As part of ongoing efforts to enhance transparency, civic engagement, and community pride, the City Manager’s Department has developed a new annual initiative; the Year in Review.
This initiative is identified as a key action item within the Corporate Communications Strategy, aimed at improving public storytelling, celebrating municipal achievements, and reinforcing the city’s strategic priorities.”
To showcase the Year in Review, staff is proposing the introduction of the Mayor’s Winter Levee to take place on Saturday, January 10.
Levees, which used to be common in the city, are an opportunity for residents to gather with the mayor and council at the start of a new year.
The venue being considered is the Horton Farmers’ Market, “which provides a central, welcoming, and community-focused venue for a winter gathering. Light refreshments from local vendors will be provided.”
An early draft of the 2025 Year in Review is included in the agenda package, and example content includes:
 Major capital and infrastructure achievements
 Community partnerships and events
 Service improvements
 Progress on the City’s Strategic Plan
 Department-specific success stories
 Photos and human-focused stories
THE ECHO CHAMBER
Referencing last week’s item on the approximately six per cent hike to the municipal property tax levy, Dawn Docker sums it up succinctly.
“The hike will hit seniors and small landlords hard.”
Kevin Smith, meanwhile, would like to live in a world where nothing ever goes up in price.
“The city hasn’t produced a budget that didn’t have a municipal tax increase in about 30 years. When it comes right down to it, we can safely say that all three levels of government are incompetent.
“Here in St. Thomas, council decided to give PowerCo a tax break until 2035, after already receiving $16 billion from the taxpayers, while Volkswagen was making profits of $29 billion from 2023-2024. “Ridiculous to give money to an extremely profitable company. I’m not saying this is a money laundering scheme, but as a taxpayer, I can’t help but feel violated because so many of us are struggling.
“The short-sightedness of council when they put this deal together was mind-boggling to me. They didn’t account for owing the county millions of dollars for land, or that they needed a $400 million upgrade to the water system in the city.
“These things are important to know if you’re a fiscally responsible politician, one would think.
“There is only a very small market for electric vehicles. The plant, if it opens at all, won’t hire even close to the thousands of people it is forecasting.
“Just like Stellantis, Algoma Steel and Cami, etc. Corporate welfare followed by job losses, that is my prediction. The pattern is obvious.”

Questions and comments may be emailed to City Scope

Visit us on Facebook

And a reminder, I can be heard weekday afternoons as news anchor and reporter on 94.1 myFM in St. Thomas. As always, your comments and input are appreciated.

Leave a Reply